In the 2025 and 2026 seasons, Lucknow Super Giants lost 17 tosses. On all 17 occasions the opposing captain made the same choice: field first, and let Lucknow bat. LSG won four of those 17 games. Over the same two seasons, when the coin fell their way, Lucknow chose to chase 10 times out of 11 and won half of those chases. One franchise, two seasons, two very different records, and the only thing separating them was who called the toss correctly.
That gap is the story of the franchise's fifth season and the clearest explanation for why a side that reached the playoffs in each of its first two years, 2022 and 2023, has now missed them three years running. Between 2022 and 2026 LSG played 72 IPL matches, won 34 and lost 37, with one washout. Inside that near-even line sits a sharp split: when opponents sent them in, Lucknow won 10 of 13 such games in 2022–23 (one was washed out) and 6 of 21 from 2024 to 2026. This piece follows that collapse season by season, using the Cricsheet ball-by-ball record from 2022 to 2025 and full scorecards through the 2026 league stage.
The Bat-First Trap: How Lucknow Became the Team Everyone Inserts
2022–2023: when batting first was LSG's weapon
Lucknow's debut season in 2022 opened badly. On 28 March 2022 at the Wankhede, they were put in by Gujarat Titans, made 158/6 and lost by five wickets, with Mohammed Shami named player of the match. That was the last time for a while that batting first hurt them. Over the rest of 2022, LSG won seven of their eight bat-first games, defending 199/4 and 168/6 against Mumbai Indians, 153/8 against Punjab Kings at Pune and, most famously, 210/0 against Kolkata Knight Riders at the DY Patil Stadium on 18 May 2022, an unbeaten opening stand that won by two runs.
The 2023 season repeated the pattern on slower surfaces. Put in by Delhi Capitals at the Ekana on 1 April 2023, Lucknow made 193/6 and won by 50 runs, with Mark Wood taking the match award. They defended 154/7 at Jaipur against Rajasthan Royals on 19 April, 257/5 at Mohali on 28 April, 177/4 against Mumbai on 16 May and 176/8 by a single run at Eden Gardens on 20 May. Excluding the 3 May washout against Chennai Super Kings, LSG won five of six games in 2023 when they batted first. Their chasing record that year was 3 wins from 8.
The key point about 2022–23 is that opponents kept inserting Lucknow (13 times across two seasons) and kept regretting it. In both seasons LSG's average first-innings score was about 178, enough on the surfaces of that period, and the bowling closed games out. In 2023 Lucknow had the second-best death-overs economy in the league (9.68 runs per over from over 16 onward), behind only Gujarat.
2024: the first crack
The 2024 season, the last under KL Rahul as captain, is where the split begins to show. Lucknow won the toss nine times and, unusually, chose to bat four times, winning two of those games. Both wins came at the Ekana: 199/8 defended against Punjab on 30 March 2024, with Mayank Yadav's express pace earning him player of the match, and 163/5 defended against Gujarat on 7 April, when Yash Thakur took the award. Mayank was player of the match again on 2 April at Bengaluru, where Lucknow had been put in and defended 181/5. The other two choices failed badly: 167/7 against Delhi was chased in 18.1 overs on 12 April, and 165/4 at Hyderabad on 8 May 2024 was overhauled in 9.4 overs without a wicket lost: a ten-wicket defeat with 62 balls to spare.
When opponents sent them in during 2024, Lucknow won two of four. Their death-overs economy slid to 11.80, eighth of ten teams, and the death wickets fell from 40 in 2023 to 19. A side that had defended a run-a-ball total in the last five overs now gave away nearly two runs a ball.
2025–2026: inserted 17 times, won four
Rishabh Pant took over the captaincy for 2025, and Lucknow became the IPL's easiest decision at the toss. Nine opponents won the toss in 2025 and all nine put Lucknow in. LSG won three of those games, all with big totals: 203/8 against Mumbai at the Ekana on 4 April, 238/3 at Eden Gardens on 8 April (won by four runs, Nicholas Pooran player of the match) and 235/2 at Ahmedabad on 22 May (Mitchell Marsh player of the match). They lost the other six, including 209/8 defended for most of a game against Delhi at Visakhapatnam before Ashutosh Sharma's one-wicket finish on 24 March 2025, and 227/3 against Royal Challengers on 27 May 2025, chased with eight balls to spare.
The 2026 season was harsher still. Eight opponents won the toss and all eight inserted LSG. The results were 141 all out against Delhi on 1 April 2026, 164/8 against Gujarat on 12 April, 146 all out at Bengaluru on 15 April, then four totals that would have won most games in 2023: 228/5 at the Wankhede (chased in 18.4 overs on 4 May), 203/8 at Chepauk (chased in 19.2 overs on 10 May), 220/5 at Jaipur (chased in 19.1 overs on 19 May) and 196/6 at the Ekana (chased in 18 overs on 23 May, Shreyas Iyer player of the match). The only bat-first win was the rain-shortened game against Royal Challengers on 7 May 2026: 209/3 in 19 overs, decided by nine runs on DLS, with Marsh player of the match again.
When Pant won the toss in 2026, he chased every time, six times out of six. Lucknow won three of those six, including a seven-wicket win against Chennai at the Ekana on 15 May (188/3 in 16.4 overs). Over 2025–26, LSG chasing by choice went 5 from 10. Batting first went 5 from 18. In 2026, Lucknow finished with four wins, nine defeats and a super-over loss to Kolkata on 26 April.
The Data Deep-Dive
Table 1 — LSG by season: batting first vs chasing
| Season | Matches | Bat-first W/P | Chasing W/P | Lost toss → inserted (W/P) | Avg 1st-innings score batting first | Defended 200+ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | 15 | 7 / 8 | 2 / 7 | 5 / 6 | 178.5 | 1 / 1 |
| 2023 | 15 | 5 / 7 (1 NR) | 3 / 8 | 5 / 7 (1 NR) | 177.3 | 1 / 1 |
| 2024 | 14 | 4 / 8 | 3 / 6 | 2 / 4 | 180.8 | 1 / 1 |
| 2025 | 14 | 4 / 10 | 2 / 4 | 3 / 9 | 199.3 | 3 / 6 |
| 2026 | 14 | 1 / 8 | 3 / 6 | 1 / 8 | 188.4 | 1 / 4 |
| Total | 72 | 21 / 41 | 13 / 31 | 16 / 34 | — | 7 / 13 |
Source: Cricsheet scorecards, 2022–2026, all LSG IPL matches including the 2022 and 2023 Eliminators. The 26 April 2026 tie against KKR, lost in the super over, is counted as a defeat.
Two figures stand out. First, Lucknow's bat-first total kept rising, from 178.5 in 2022 to 199.3 in 2025, and their win rate batting first still fell from 88% to 40% to 13%. Scoring more did not help because the league's scoring rose faster. Second, the toss column. Lucknow lost 42 tosses in five seasons and were sent in 34 times. From 2025 onwards, every opponent that won the toss against LSG chose to field.
Table 2 — Death-overs bowling (overs 16–20), LSG vs the league
| Season | LSG economy | LSG death wickets | LSG rank (of 10) | Best team that season |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | 11.14 | 29 | 10th | Gujarat Titans, 9.37 |
| 2023 | 9.68 | 40 | 2nd | Gujarat Titans, 9.44 |
| 2024 | 11.80 | 19 | 8th | Kolkata Knight Riders, 9.99 |
| 2025 | 11.27 | 27 | 8th | Kolkata Knight Riders, 9.88 |
Source: Cricsheet ball-by-ball, IPL 2022–2025, overs 16–20 of both innings; wickets exclude run-outs.
The 2022 row is the outlier, and it explains why that season still worked. Lucknow had the league's worst death economy in 2022 and still won seven of eight bat-first games, because Quinton de Kock, Rahul and Deepak Hooda put up totals that the bowling in the first 15 overs could protect. By 2025 that cushion was gone. Of the regular death bowlers in 2025, only Digvesh Rathi (9.80 across 60 balls) beat ten an over. Avesh Khan bowled the most death balls (111) at 10.97, and Shardul Thakur went at 11.73. In 2024, Mohsin Khan (12.91) and Yash Thakur (12.87) both conceded more than two runs a ball at the death.
Table 3 — Why the league inserts: defending 200 has stopped being safe
| Season | First-innings totals of 200+ | Defended | Defence rate | All bat-first wins (league) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | 13 | 11 | 85% | 37 / 74 |
| 2023 | 24 | 16 | 67% | 40 / 73 |
| 2024 | 26 | 21 | 81% | 35 / 71 |
| 2025 | 32 | 24 | 75% | 33 / 70 |
| 2026 | 38 | 21 | 55% | 27 / 72 |
Source: Cricsheet scorecards, completed IPL matches with a result.
This is the context for Lucknow's 2026. In 2024, a 200-plus first innings won four times in five. In 2026, it barely won more than half the time, and teams batting first won 27 of 72 decided matches, 37.5%. Every captain who won the toss against LSG was doing what the numbers said. Lucknow's problem was not that they were inserted, since every team was. It was that they were inserted more often than most, by losing the toss, and had the weakest defence against a chase.
Legacy Impact — What This Means for Lucknow Now
Five seasons in, LSG's identity has flipped. The 2022–23 Lucknow was a bat-first, squeeze-and-defend side: Ravi Bishnoi and Krunal Pandya in the middle overs, a varied pace attack at the death, and totals built around 175. That side reached two Eliminators and lost both, to Rajat Patidar's 112* at Eden Gardens on 25 May 2022 and to Akash Madhwal's 5 for 5 at Chepauk on 24 May 2023. The 2025–26 Lucknow is a power-hitting side (Pant, Pooran, Marsh, Aiden Markram) that scores close to 200 batting first and still cannot defend it.
The roster for the next cycle points both ways. The arrival of Mohammed Shami, who was player of the match in LSG's first-ever IPL game in 2022 and was Lucknow's player of the match at Hyderabad on 5 April 2026, adds a proven new-ball and death-overs operator. Anrich Nortje brings 150 kph pace. Mayank Yadav's fitness remains the biggest unknown: the 2024 data shows what he does for a defence, since both of his player-of-the-match awards came while protecting a total. The structural fix is not more runs. LSG's 2025 bat-first average of 199.3 was already the highest in franchise history. The fix is the 30 balls after the 15th over of the second innings, where Lucknow ranked eighth in both 2024 and 2025.
The toss matters here as well. At the Ekana, LSG's batting-first record in 2026 was one win from four (and that win was rain-shortened). Their three home chases brought a 40-run defeat to Rajasthan, a super-over loss to Kolkata and a seven-wicket win over Chennai. A venue that once rewarded batting first and squeezing has, on current evidence, become a chasing ground like most others. For more on how the toss swung the 2026 season league-wide, see our toss impact analysis.
This is exactly the kind of split that CricMind's Oracle is built to price. The pre-match model factors in the toss once it is known, and that matters most for a side whose bat-first win rate has fallen to 13% while its chasing rate holds near 50%. Try it yourself in the Matchup Machine, and read the earlier chapters of the Lucknow story in our pieces on the five-season decline and the lost middle-overs squeeze.
Three Takeaways
- The toss has decided LSG's season twice in a row. In 2025–26 Lucknow won 5 of 10 when chasing by choice and 4 of 17 when inserted. No other side lost as many tosses and was inserted every time across those two years.
- Higher totals did not fix the problem. LSG's bat-first average climbed from 178.5 (2022) to 199.3 (2025), while their bat-first win rate fell from 88% to 13% by 2026. League-wide, 200 defended four times in five in 2024 and barely half the time in 2026.
- Death bowling is the variable that matches the results. Lucknow's only season with a top-two death economy (9.68 in 2023) was a playoff year in which they won five of six decided games batting first. The 2026 squad's Shami, Nortje, Avesh and Mayank Yadav have to bring that number back towards ten.
FAQ
What is LSG's record batting first vs chasing in the IPL?
From 2022 to 2026, Lucknow Super Giants won 21 of 41 matches batting first and 13 of 31 chasing. The split has reversed over time: 7 from 8 batting first in 2022, but 1 from 8 in 2026, when their chasing record was 3 from 6.
How many times was LSG put in to bat in 2025 and 2026?
Seventeen. Lucknow lost the toss nine times in 2025 and eight times in 2026, and every opponent chose to field. LSG won four of those 17 matches.
Why did LSG lose so many games after scoring 200?
Across 2025 and 2026, LSG defended four of ten first-innings totals of 200 or more. League-wide, the defence rate for 200-plus totals fell from 81% in 2024 to 55% in 2026, and Lucknow's death-overs economy ranked eighth of ten teams in both 2024 and 2025.
What was LSG's best season?
By results, 2022: nine league wins and a third-place finish, followed in 2023 by 17 points and third place again. Both seasons ended in the Eliminator, against Royal Challengers in 2022 and Mumbai Indians in 2023.
Has LSG ever won the IPL?
No. Lucknow Super Giants entered the IPL in 2022 and reached the playoffs in 2022 and 2023, losing the Eliminator both times. They missed the playoffs in 2024, 2025 and 2026.
Who captains Lucknow Super Giants?
Rishabh Pant has captained LSG since 2025, with Justin Langer as head coach. KL Rahul led the side from 2022 to 2024.
Does winning the toss help LSG at the Ekana?
In 2026, LSG won one of four home games batting first (a DLS result) and won one of their three home chases outright, against Chennai, after losing another chase to Rajasthan and a super over to Kolkata. The ground's old reputation as a bat-first venue has faded.
Data: Cricsheet IPL scorecards 2022–2026 and ball-by-ball records 2022–2025. Analysis by CricMind.